Cecil Moore wrote:

Hi John, one important fact that some people would like to
forget is that the reflected wave can indeed be partitioned
from the forward wave. Some people on this newsgroup argue
that the forward wave and reflected wave are inseparable and
that reflected waves contain no rearward traveling energy.

However a circulator plus load resistor located at the source
will prevent reflected wave energy from being incident upon
the source and will heat up that load resistor in the process
proving that reflected waves are real and do contain energy.

Hi Cecil

How much energy is "in the reflected wave" without a circulator load
resistor?

73, ac6xg