Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
![]() |
|||
|
|||
![]()
Some time ago I mentioned how inefficient Yagi design
antennas were thinking more in the way of how little of the radiation used got to its required direction. At that time people said the antenna was efficient though they wanted to talk about actual radiation efficiency and the sniping began ..Nobody but nobody came back with the radiation efficiency of a Yagi as they saw the question, they just wanted to throw stones.Imagine that antennas was not what the experts wanted to talk about and the newsgroup took a turn for the worst So I join in with the thoughts of radiation efficiency of a yagi unless you prefere to give up this antenna newsgroup. But before you scream out and throw stones again I will referr to efficiency as most of the members of this group what's left of them think of the term. So let's look at that if that is what you preferr.. The basic small yagi has three elements one driven, one a reflector and one a director yet only one element has a truly resistive impedance whereas the other two do not. Since two elements out of the three are producing reactive impedances and wherein the reactive portions of impedance is pure waste pray tell me how one can consider a yagi as efficient? And please, please don't waste time on "I don't understand" otherwise everything drops down to the subject of spark noise which was really decided by hams a long while ago. On the other side of the coin, if the reactive portion of an impedance is not waste then why is LCR type mesh circuitry only revolve around lumped circuitry? HINT add up the power emminating from each element P =I sq times real resistance for those who are just followers. There again maybe it is best that you be honest and say you don't understand! Better that than join those who have nothing to say about antennas! |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Yagi efficiency | Antenna | |||
Yagi efficiency | Antenna | |||
Tape Measure Yagi Antenna Questions | Antenna | |||
SUPER J-POLE BEATS YAGI BY 1 dB | Antenna | |||
Yagi, OWA and Wideband Yagi etc etc | Antenna |