RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Antenna (https://www.radiobanter.com/antenna/)
-   -   4nec2 hidden variables. (https://www.radiobanter.com/antenna/172498-4nec2-hidden-variables.html)

Dave Platt August 19th 11 01:49 AM

direction finding
 
As far as VHF, I know a couple here in town I've seen using arrays
for direction finding. But they used four verticals in a square.
It worked quite well. We had one guy that kept jamming one of the
repeaters, and the user of said array was easily capable of tracking
him down to a shopping center parking lot where the guy was sitting
in his car. I suspect the expression on the jammers face when the
tracker tapped on his window was priceless. :)
The device in the car used an array of LED's in a cross configuration
if I remember right.
He had the antenna array on the back of his truck. I don't recall the
element spacing.


Likely a Doppler direction-finder, possibly a Ramsey DDF-1 or one of
the others of that sort.

They aren't perfect... definitely subject to errors due to multipath,
and they works best when looking for a relatively clean, non-modulated
carrier. Fun, though... I've used mine on several occasions to locate
sources of QRM or jamming.

I've seen similar 4-vertical arrays on the roofs of some police cars
in my area. I infer that they're used to track down cars which have
had their Lojack locators triggered, after a car theft.

--
Dave Platt AE6EO
Friends of Jade Warrior home page: http://www.radagast.org/jade-warrior
I do _not_ wish to receive unsolicited commercial email, and I will
boycott any company which has the gall to send me such ads!

Jim Lux August 19th 11 05:33 PM

direction finding
 
On 8/18/2011 5:49 PM, Dave Platt wrote:

I've seen similar 4-vertical arrays on the roofs of some police cars
in my area. I infer that they're used to track down cars which have
had their Lojack locators triggered, after a car theft.


You are correct with respect to LoJack, which radiates in the high VHF
band. They do pseudo-doppler direction finding. I don't know how
fashionable LoJack is these days... the sophisticated thieves know how
to jam it. The widespread deployment of in-car GPS/cell (On-Star, etc)
covers a lot of the other cases. Face it, most car thieves aren't all
that smart.

Jeff Liebermann[_2_] August 19th 11 06:30 PM

direction finding
 
On Thu, 18 Aug 2011 17:49:21 -0700, (Dave Platt)
wrote:

Likely a Doppler direction-finder, possibly a Ramsey DDF-1 or one of
the others of that sort.


Agreed. There are various commerical implimentations. Basically, the
diameter of the "circle" of antennas controls the deviation of the
doppler signal heard on the receiver. The bigger the diameter, that
better the signal to noise ratio. Typical is about 1/2 wave diameter.
Smaller diameters will work, but require narrower digital filters
which slow down aquisition.

They aren't perfect... definitely subject to errors due to multipath,
and they works best when looking for a relatively clean, non-modulated
carrier.


Plenty more wrong with doppler DF. They don't like horizontally
polarized signals. Reflections cause false readings. Forward
alignment (0 degree heading) varies somewhat with frequency. Switching
PIN diodes in the antenna cause interpolation errors every 90 degrees.
Multiple transmitters on the same frequency result in erronious
readings. Antenna tilt causes big errors. Reflections off building
and in particular, the ground ahead of the antenna, causes errors.
There are fixes and work around for most of these, but I haven't seen
any on ham quality dopplers. Some of my ancient comments on the
topic:
http://www.qsl.net/n9zia/doppler_notes1.txt
http://www.qsl.net/n9zia/doppler_notes2.txt

Fun, though... I've used mine on several occasions to locate
sources of QRM or jamming.


Ummm.... How did you get it to produce a usable bearing if there were
two transmitters on the air at the same time? I can see if it you
waited until the jammer was the only carrier, but few jammers allow
that to happen. Mostly we use doppler for the traditional stuck
transmitter.

Mini-rant: Why do almost ALL commerical radios have tx timeout
timers, while almost ALL ham radios don't have this feature?

I've seen similar 4-vertical arrays on the roofs of some police cars
in my area. I infer that they're used to track down cars which have
had their Lojack locators triggered, after a car theft.


That's LoJack. I rode around in test vehicle with one trying to make
sense of the indication. In an urban jungle, it's very difficult to
get a decent bearing due to all the building reflections. I suggested
we try an elevated freeway, and the bearings improved. Works much
better in the suburbs.

--
Jeff Liebermann

150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

Sal[_3_] August 19th 11 08:59 PM

direction finding
 

"Jeff Liebermann" wrote in message
...

snip

Mini-rant: Why do almost ALL commerical radios have tx timeout
timers, while almost ALL ham radios don't have this feature?


Is it because we're all known to be gasbags?

Timeout? Why the very *impudence* of that radio!!!

All kidding aside, we had a major repeater outage in San Diego some years
ago. A 50w mobile, in the middle of a hotel parking lot, was on the air for
hours, holdng the repeater. The T-hunters who found the car ID'ed the owner
by his callsign plate and contacted him in the hotel. It was the old
microphone-between-the-seat-cushions trick. Timeout would have helped that
day.

"Sal"



Dave Platt August 19th 11 09:12 PM

direction finding
 
In article ,
Jeff Liebermann wrote:

Fun, though... I've used mine on several occasions to locate
sources of QRM or jamming.


Ummm.... How did you get it to produce a usable bearing if there were
two transmitters on the air at the same time? I can see if it you
waited until the jammer was the only carrier, but few jammers allow
that to happen. Mostly we use doppler for the traditional stuck
transmitter.


A lot of the jamming in question is jamming of repeaters, so you are
DF'ing on the repeater's input frequency.

If you have a rough idea where the jammer is operating, you can often
get a Doppler detector (e.g. on a car) into that area and get a decent
signal from it when he's jamming... but be far enough away from the
person being jammed that you don't hear any of his signal (although
the repeater does).

A Dopper rig on the roof of a car has a far smaller line-of-sight
radius than a repeater receiver mounted up on a high building or
hilltop.

--
Dave Platt AE6EO
Friends of Jade Warrior home page: http://www.radagast.org/jade-warrior
I do _not_ wish to receive unsolicited commercial email, and I will
boycott any company which has the gall to send me such ads!

Jeff Liebermann[_2_] August 19th 11 09:49 PM

direction finding
 
On Fri, 19 Aug 2011 12:59:57 -0700, "Sal" wrote:


"Jeff Liebermann" wrote in message
.. .

snip

Mini-rant: Why do almost ALL commerical radios have tx timeout
timers, while almost ALL ham radios don't have this feature?


Is it because we're all known to be gasbags?


Yes. That's also why many Japanese ham radios are severely lacking in
microphone gain. I guess they assume that all Americans are always
yelling.

Timeout? Why the very *impudence* of that radio!!!


Ok, bad choice of a name for the timer. Perhaps "anti-ratchet mouth"
or "monolog restrictor" might be better.

All kidding aside, we had a major repeater outage in San Diego some years
ago. A 50w mobile, in the middle of a hotel parking lot, was on the air for
hours, holdng the repeater. The T-hunters who found the car ID'ed the owner
by his callsign plate and contacted him in the hotel. It was the old
microphone-between-the-seat-cushions trick. Timeout would have helped that
day.


Yep. It's all too common. My guess is one every month or so.
Unfortunately, I managed to jam the microphone under the debris pile
that usually clutters the passenger seat, jamming the local repeater.
I was easily identified by the classical music in the background since
nobody else around listens to classical music. What's really
irritating are the number of packet radios that end up on repeater
frequencies. Usually, we can decode the call sign and contact the
culprit. Occasionally, there's no call sign as the owner is trying to
setup his TNC. There's also the stuck transmitter on commercial and
public safety frequencies. Those are fun and gets us plenty of points
from the various agencies. Extra credit to the local comm shop that
likes to defeat the timeout timer, for no obvious reason.

My favorite stuck transmitter was on marine channel 16. There was a
very strong carrier on Ch 16, that could be heard all over Monterey
Bay. Everyone dug out their DF hardware and the searching began.
Strong signal, no modulation, 100% duty cycle. This should be easy.
Right...

After 5 days of bad guesses and dead ends, the culprit turned out to
be a marine base station on Fremont Pk (3,000ft). It was rarely used
and was only functional in order to maintain the license. Something
went wrong with the DC wireline control system (with no timer) which
stuck it on the air. Why so difficult? The strong signal created a
wide assortment of reflections. Everyone had trouble separating the
strong reflections from the incident signal with the Doppler DF boxes.
I was using my rotating antenna kludge, but stupidly used a 5 element
yagi tuned to 146Mhz. At 156.8Mhz, I later discovered that it had
almost as much gain towards the back of the antenna as it did in the
forward direction.

Incidentally, there's another difference between ham and commercial
mobiles. Commercial mobiles have a PL hang up function, where the
receiver is in PL decode when the mic is hung in the hanger, and goes
to carrier squelch when removed. Many ham mobiles seem to be missing
this useful feature.


--
Jeff Liebermann
150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

dave August 19th 11 10:00 PM

direction finding
 
Jeff Liebermann wrote:


Incidentally, there's another difference between ham and commercial
mobiles. Commercial mobiles have a PL hang up function, where the
receiver is in PL decode when the mic is hung in the hanger, and goes
to carrier squelch when removed. Many ham mobiles seem to be missing
this useful feature.



This is so the commercial operator listen to the whole channel (and not
just his company's CTCSS filtered traffic) prior to transmitting. A
typical ham channel is continuously monitored and everyone has the
same CTCSS tone.

Jeff Liebermann[_2_] August 19th 11 10:20 PM

direction finding
 
On 19 Aug 2011 21:00:51 GMT, dave wrote:

Jeff Liebermann wrote:
Incidentally, there's another difference between ham and commercial
mobiles. Commercial mobiles have a PL hang up function, where the
receiver is in PL decode when the mic is hung in the hanger, and goes
to carrier squelch when removed. Many ham mobiles seem to be missing
this useful feature.


This is so the commercial operator listen to the whole channel (and not
just his company's CTCSS filtered traffic) prior to transmitting. A
typical ham channel is continuously monitored and everyone has the
same CTCSS tone.


Sure, but we have several other distant repeaters on the same channels
I like to monitor. I also hear plenty of RF leaks and odd sources of
RF as I drive around. So, I turn on the PL decode. With a ham radio,
I just pickup the mic, the receiver stays in PL decode, and proceed to
talk. With the Maxtrac I currently use in the car, as soon as I
pickup the mic, I hear all the junk, which helps to make sure I'm not
causing a problem by talking over other users on the distant
repeaters. (We have somewhat overlapping coverage areas). Also, when
in PL decode, there's about a 600msec delay before the rx squelch
opens, which obliterates the first two syllables.

--
Jeff Liebermann
150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558

Rob[_8_] August 20th 11 09:26 AM

direction finding
 
Jeff Liebermann wrote:
TNC. There's also the stuck transmitter on commercial and
public safety frequencies. Those are fun and gets us plenty of points
from the various agencies. Extra credit to the local comm shop that
likes to defeat the timeout timer, for no obvious reason.


It does not seem the public safety radio devices always had this
timeout timer either.
Before the public safety services here switched to a digital system,
they used NBFM equipment from companies like Motorola, and it was very
common to hear stuck transmitters that blocked an entire repeater channel.
(which often consists of multiple receivers and transmitters over a city area)

Police used mobile transceivers in the cars on VHF and portables on UHF
so it usually was possible to alert the users on the other channel and
hope the stuck PTT key was found that way, but on major events like
queen's day it often happened that the portables channel was jammed for
half an hour or so before the culprit was found.

Of course the equipment was aging by that time, it probably was from
the eighties. Now they are all on TETRA and AFAIK that system allows
the operator to just tune out stuck transmitters or devices that fell
into wrong hands.

Jeff Liebermann[_2_] August 20th 11 04:43 PM

direction finding
 
On 20 Aug 2011 08:26:15 GMT, Rob wrote:

Jeff Liebermann wrote:
TNC. There's also the stuck transmitter on commercial and
public safety frequencies. Those are fun and gets us plenty of points
from the various agencies. Extra credit to the local comm shop that
likes to defeat the timeout timer, for no obvious reason.


It does not seem the public safety radio devices always had this
timeout timer either.


Methinks that just about every radio, by Motorola and Kenwood have a
transmit timeout timer.
http://802.11junk.com/jeffl/pics/drivel/slides/too-many-radios.html
The dip switch programmable radios (SP10) do not have a timer, but
literally every radio that requires a computah to setup has a timer.
Note that I was talking about mobile radios all of which are
programmable, not handhelds.

Before the public safety services here switched to a digital system,
they used NBFM equipment from companies like Motorola, and it was very
common to hear stuck transmitters that blocked an entire repeater channel.
(which often consists of multiple receivers and transmitters over a city area)


That's a programming issue. The timer is off by default and must be
enabled and set for a specific number of seconds. 60 seconds is the
typical timeout.

Digital radio comes in many flavors. One of the big advantages of
digital is that the repeater and channel can handle more than one
transmission at a time (either by TDM or FDM). Therefore a stuck
digital transmitter does not timeout or disable the repeater. In
addition, many such radios are full duplex, which allows the
dispatcher or comm shop to remotely disable the transmitter and yell
at the user. Whether the PSAP is setup and trained to do this is
debatable.

Police used mobile transceivers in the cars on VHF and portables on UHF
so it usually was possible to alert the users on the other channel and
hope the stuck PTT key was found that way, but on major events like
queen's day it often happened that the portables channel was jammed for
half an hour or so before the culprit was found.


Yep. Simply identifying the stuck transmitter is often insufficient.
I've heard stuck transmitters in vehicles rolling down the freeway for
an hour with a stuck transmitter. It was obvious who it was but
nothing short of an RF seeking missile was going to get their
attention. In one case, someone noticed that they were listening to
specific local radio station. The dispatcher called the radio station
and had them make a special announcement to the driver to unstick the
transmitter. It worked, instantly.

Of course the equipment was aging by that time, it probably was from
the eighties. Now they are all on TETRA and AFAIK that system allows
the operator to just tune out stuck transmitters or devices that fell
into wrong hands.


Yep. Nice feature. In the US, the high end radios are P25. Various
other narrow band solutions exist, most of which have remote
programming and remote deactivation. Despite all the government
programs intended to provide interoperability, the manufacturers (and
the FCC) have gone out of their way to introduce proprietary
enhancements and introduce intentional incompatibility.


--
Jeff Liebermann
150 Felker St #D
http://www.LearnByDestroying.com
Santa Cruz CA 95060 http://802.11junk.com
Skype: JeffLiebermann AE6KS 831-336-2558


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com