February 15th 06, 03:41 PM
posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
Gene Fuller
Posts: n/a
Orthogonality relation between modes in Dielectric-Lined CircularWaveguide (or with concentric dielectric layers)
Did you actually read the paper you referenced?
Two points:
The authors note on the third page that they could not find any prior
derivation of the orthonormality relationships for this configuration.
The paper was published in 2000, so it should be an easy library
research project to find any subsequent papers that reference this work.
Appendix A goes through the derivation of the orthonormality
relationships in excruciating detail. Every step is outlined, including
the integration tricks. It is unlikely that you would find any paper, or
even a textbook, that is more detailed.