K7ITM wrote:
So, PLEASE wake up and quit trying to attribute this "lumped circuit"
stuff, and the completely independent charge quantization stuff, to
this discussion. It simply is NOT there. It is absolutely NOT the
point of all this.

I agree so please tell that to everyone who is defending the
lumped circuit presuppositions. One cannot use the presuppositions
of the lumped circuit model to prove those same presuppositions!!!

If your current charge concepts disagree with Maxwell's equations,
Maxwell's equations win *EVERY* time. Maxwell's equations do not
require individual charge carriers. They work just fine considering
only fields in the aether.

And PLEASE wake up and quit screwing up the attributions on this
newsgroup. You didn't say the above! I said the above. Why do
you deliberately falsify the attributions? Such is illegal in Texas.
--
73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp