RadioBanter

RadioBanter (https://www.radiobanter.com/)
-   Homebrew (https://www.radiobanter.com/homebrew/)
-   -   PCB Layout S/W Recmondations? (https://www.radiobanter.com/homebrew/127030-pcb-layout-s-w-recmondations.html)

John Tartar November 12th 07 03:02 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.

bob prohaska's usenet account November 12th 07 03:35 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
John Tartar wrote:
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard format.

It might be worthwhile to look at the various ports in the FreeBSD
CAD library. Chipmunk and electric are among them, though neither seems
to emphasise PCB layout. Perhaps there are other, more appropriate offerings.
http://www.freebsd.org/ports/cad.html is a reasonable place to start

Good luck,

bob prohaska

Ian White GM3SEK November 12th 07 09:21 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
John Tartar wrote:
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


My magazine column has been asking for similar recommendations for free
software.

ExpressPCB is an excellent deal for anyone who is not affected by its
restrictions (which I think are quite fair); but that doesn't help in
John's situation.

Someone recently recommended Kicad, a free open-source software suite
covering schematic entry, board layout, Gerber view and 3D views:

http://www.lis.inpg.fr/realise_au_lis/kicad

I haven't had time to explore beyond the web page, but would be very
interested in comments and evaluations.


--

73 from Ian GM3SEK 'In Practice' columnist for RadCom (RSGB)
http://www.ifwtech.co.uk/g3sek

Joel Koltner November 12th 07 06:20 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
"John Tartar" wrote in message
. 70...
I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


If your volume gets higher you'll have the money to purchase software, right?

Of course, there are some pretty good 100% free options: KiCAD and gEDA being
the most well-known.

Advanced Circuits has some "free" software like ExpressPCB but you do have the
option of getting the real Gerbers (not just some proprrietary format) back
after your first order with them (see:
http://www.4pcb.com/index.php?load=content&page_id=46) -- this strikes me as
an entirely fair arrangement.

---Joel



Tim Wescott November 12th 07 06:33 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
John Tartar wrote:
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


I'm using Eagle. I like it just fine. You can do 80x100mm 2-layer
boards for free, and the step up to bigger 4-layer boards is either $50
or $150 -- in either case it's cheap.

--

Tim Wescott
Wescott Design Services
http://www.wescottdesign.com

Do you need to implement control loops in software?
"Applied Control Theory for Embedded Systems" gives you just what it says.
See details at http://www.wescottdesign.com/actfes/actfes.html

xpyttl November 12th 07 11:58 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 

"Joel Koltner" wrote in message
...

Of course, there are some pretty good 100% free options: KiCAD and gEDA
being the most well-known.


The Fedora project just released a custom Live CD oriented toward
electronics development. It includes gEDA, as well as kicad, so this is a
pretty painless way to try it out. hmmm ... I can't seem to find the
original link at fedoraproject, but a quick google shows dozens of places it
can be downloaded from ... google on "Fedora Electronic Lab"

...



Dr. Grok November 13th 07 12:50 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
John Tartar wrote in
. 70:

Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard
format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my
applications and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use
other vendors when the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


Try gEDA -- free. Full suite of design software. Contain gschem to do
the schematic, then export to pcb [also in the package]. You can print
the layout 1:1 on a transparancy and make your own boards if you want.

Dr. G.

Highland Ham November 13th 07 10:38 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recommendations?
 
xpyttl wrote:
"Joel Koltner" wrote in message
...

Of course, there are some pretty good 100% free options: KiCAD and gEDA
being the most well-known.


The Fedora project just released a custom Live CD oriented toward
electronics development. It includes gEDA, as well as kicad, so this is a
pretty painless way to try it out. hmmm ... I can't seem to find the
original link at fedoraproject, but a quick google shows dozens of places it
can be downloaded from ... google on "Fedora Electronic Lab"

===========================
I found gEDA at one of the Mandriva Linux repositories ....excellent.
Tnx for the info.

The prog is highly likely also available at an Ubuntu Linux repository.

Frank GM0CSZ / KN6WH

John Tartar November 13th 07 06:26 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
"Dr. Grok" wrote in news:ox6_i.1105$OJ.401@trndny06:

John Tartar wrote in
. 70:

Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard
format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my
applications and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use
other vendors when the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


Try gEDA -- free. Full suite of design software. Contain gschem to do
the schematic, then export to pcb [also in the package]. You can print
the layout 1:1 on a transparancy and make your own boards if you want.

Dr. G.


Thanks for all the suggestions. However, I should have mentioned that I'm
using Windows 98.

1) gEDA appears to be only for Linux & Mac.

2) I installed PCB artist, but thee's no component libraries, and the
prices for the small runs are about $100 higher than Express PCB

3) I'm not doing this for porfit, Ham radio is my hobby not my job, so
anything boards I make I will either give away, or sell at cost.

4) I'm off to try Eagle that Tim receomnded, 80x100mm 2 payer boards are
fine, all my designs are in PCB Expresses miniboard format.

bjorn drefeldt November 13th 07 07:09 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
John Tartar wrote:
"Dr. Grok" wrote in news:ox6_i.1105$OJ.401@trndny06:


John Tartar wrote in
. 3.70:


Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard
format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my
applications and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use
other vendors when the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


Try gEDA -- free. Full suite of design software. Contain gschem to do
the schematic, then export to pcb [also in the package]. You can print
the layout 1:1 on a transparancy and make your own boards if you want.

Dr. G.



Thanks for all the suggestions. However, I should have mentioned that I'm
using Windows 98.

1) gEDA appears to be only for Linux & Mac.

2) I installed PCB artist, but thee's no component libraries, and the
prices for the small runs are about $100 higher than Express PCB

3) I'm not doing this for porfit, Ham radio is my hobby not my job, so
anything boards I make I will either give away, or sell at cost.

4) I'm off to try Eagle that Tim receomnded, 80x100mm 2 payer boards are
fine, all my designs are in PCB Expresses miniboard format.


I have used Protel Autotrax downloaded from
http://www.altium.com/Community/Support/Downloads/
It is DOS program but works perfectly with Windows 98
It can generate gerber files (industry standard) and has no board size
limitation

xpyttl November 13th 07 11:58 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 

"John Tartar" wrote in message
. 70...


Thanks for all the suggestions. However, I should have mentioned that I'm
using Windows 98.

1) gEDA appears to be only for Linux & Mac.


??? I'm running it on XP (and Linux, too) -- there are standalone compiles
as well as Cygwin.

2) I installed PCB artist, but thee's no component libraries, and the
prices for the small runs are about $100 higher than Express PCB


Again, where are you getting this stuff?? The main problem seems to be that
there are so many libraries that it is difficult to locate the part you want
amidst all the noise

...



David Harmon November 14th 07 04:07 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
On Tue, 13 Nov 2007 18:26:51 -0000 in rec.radio.amateur.homebrew, John
Tartar wrote,
4) I'm off to try Eagle that Tim receomnded, 80x100mm 2 payer boards are
fine, all my designs are in PCB Expresses miniboard format.


I am also happy with the free version of Eagle, and I have run it under
Windows 98 in the past.

Joel Koltner November 14th 07 05:04 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
"John Tartar" wrote in message
. 70...
1) gEDA appears to be only for Linux & Mac.


People occasionally threaten to do Windows ports and some even begin, but
yeah, it doesn't exact seem to be "well supported" under Windows.

2) I installed PCB artist, but thee's no component libraries, and the
prices for the small runs are about $100 higher than Express PCB


Advanced Circuits will sell you 3 PCBs up to 60 sq. inches on a 2-layer board
for $99 (http://www.4pcb.com/index.php?load=content&page_id=130) ... if you
can de-panelize them yourself, it might be cheaper that way.

3) I'm not doing this for porfit, Ham radio is my hobby not my job, so
anything boards I make I will either give away, or sell at cost.


If you're going to sell them anyway, I can't imagine anyone will protest if
you tack on something extra to begin upgrading your software or hardware. :-)

4) I'm off to try Eagle that Tim receomnded, 80x100mm 2 payer boards are
fine, all my designs are in PCB Expresses miniboard format.


Eagle is good...

---Joel



H. P. Friedrichs November 16th 07 11:01 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
ExpressPCB will sell you industry standard Gerbers of artwork generated
by their free software for $50, as I recall.

73,

Pete
AC7ZL


John Tartar wrote:
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.


David Harmon November 18th 07 06:36 AM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
On Fri, 16 Nov 2007 16:01:06 -0700 in rec.radio.amateur.homebrew, "H. P.
Friedrichs" wrote,
ExpressPCB will sell you industry standard Gerbers of artwork generated
by their free software for $50, as I recall.


Which is basically paying ransom to get back your designs which are
being held hostage.


Joel Koltner November 18th 07 09:45 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
"David Harmon" wrote in message
...
Which is basically paying ransom to get back your designs which are
being held hostage.


It is, but given that they gave you the design software for free, it's a
pretty reasonable business proposition if you're aware of everything when you
start doing business with them -- no one forces you to use that free software,
after all.





Alt Beer November 21st 07 10:50 PM

PCB Layout S/W Recmondations?
 
"John Tartar" wrote in message
. 70...
Does anyone know of a simple, but free PCB layout software.

Or a way to convert .pcb files from EXPRESSPCB to industry standard
format.

I currently use ExpressPCBs layout s/w which is fine for my applications
and great for prototypes. But I want the option to use other vendors when
the volume gets high, i.e. selling kits.



FreePCB (completely free) http://www.freepcb.com/

CirCad (Omniglyph V5 has a free version) http://www.holophase.com/




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com