RadioBanter - Here is how we can end all the silly antenna questions on the repeaters and on usenet.

Interesting

"Fred G." wrote in message
...
"james" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 6 Oct 2006 16:52:24 -0400, "Fred G."
wrote:

+++Neither the Code NOR Theory tests will weed out the bad radio
operator
any
+++more than a driving test will weed out the DUIs - OR - the Physical
agility,
+++legal and other exams will weed out bad cops. Those tests are only
tests of
+++"Proficiency" in the subject matter - NOT - "Mentality". Those tests
won't
+++stop the trash.
+++But those who choose to not learn code will continue to bitch about
why
they
+++shouldn't. OK, DROP the code........Next you'll want the "Theory"
taken
away
+++too. Want to bet?
+++
+++Fred G.
*******************

Fred

The theory questions even the extra exam is not that difficult. A
decent electronics tech with an AA degree can master that test. In
fact the tests are so dummied down that just about anyone that has the
ability read and comprehend can pass them with the minimal of
coaching. So if you think so highly your "Theory" tests then I hate to
burst your bubble.

Why should proficiency in one means of communication hender operation
in another? I tend to think that those that are very proficient with
morse code tend to spend more of their time with that mode of
communication. Why should there be a limitation on other modes that do
not wish to use that mode? Most hams learn morse code and then forget
it. I have no issue with showing proficiency in a means of
communication to get priviledges. I have no issues with showing a
proficiency with "theory" as a means of priviledges.

The thing here is usage of the airwaves is a priviledge and not a
right. So what ever the government cares to do in this avenue is fine
with me. I will take advantage of what ever they offer me.

james

James,

Rethink what I wrote. I'm not claiming the tests are "all that"........
You
are right, they ARE dummied down and NO, you do NOT need an AA degree to
pass the Extra. Just some diligent studying. I was merely saying NEITHER
test will eliminate the crap - for starters. BUT those who "are" whining
about the code - if they get their wish, will then want the written exam
dropped too. In other words - FREE - uninhibited passage. IF we gave Drs',
Lawyers, Drivers, Pilots and other licenses away like some want the Ham
licenses handed out, where would we be? Ham radio may not be all that, but
it is what it is. Anything more stripped away from it - and it won't be
worth having.

"I" had to learn the code, it really is no big deal. Do I use it? Not
much,
but I'm still glad I learned it. It was a matter of self discipline. Hey,
drop the code......Who am "I" to force it down anyone's throat? That isn't
my aim or argument. Again - you're going to see the push for the rest to
be
dropped too - some just aren't satisfied. Mark my words.

Fred G.