| Page 1 of 2 | 1 | 2 |
|
|
Antenna Confusion
I've had my R75 for about 2 years now.
I purchased an Antenna Supermarket dipole, the one with the sealed traps, for the radio. Then I went and had the Kiwa mods done. All in all, a very nice setup. And like everyone says, it's great at Utility listening. But lately, I've been wanting to dig out more of those tough foreign country broadcast signals. Last night was absolutely horrible for listening to foreign stations. Only received a few of the strongest ones that were beamed at N. America. So I figured I'd try something different. I took a piece of speaker wire, about 25' long, twisted the 2 wires together at each end, stuck one end into the R75 longwire input, and threw the rest out of my basement window (yes my radio is in the basement). So, I took the remaining 15 feet of wire and looped it into a bush along the side of my house. It must be all of 5' off the ground. Back inside I go, not expecting much from the wire. I tuned to a station I knew I could receive and voila! It came in nicely. I switched back and forth from the wire to the dipole and no difference. Hmmmm, strange! I tuned in a few other stations that were weaker and again, no difference. Amazing! Did I waste my money on the Dipole antenna? I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. Now I'm wondering if the Dipole has any advantages over the long wire. Could some kind soul please explain what is happening? Any recommendations? Is there a "SW Antennas for Dummies" site somewhere? Thank you, Lenny |
"Lenny" wrote:
I've had my R75 for about 2 years now. I purchased an Antenna Supermarket dipole, the one with the sealed traps, The traps make the dipole resonant at specific frequencies. On those frequencies the dipole will exhibit the normal broadside pattern. Trap dipoles tend to have narrow resonant bandwidths at the lower frequencies Last night was absolutely horrible for listening to foreign stations. Only received a few of the strongest ones that were beamed at N. America. Probably just propagation. I took a piece of speaker wire, about 25' long, twisted the 2 wires together at each end, stuck snip I switched back and forth from the wire to the dipole and no difference. Hmmmm, strange! I tuned in a few other stations that were weaker and again, no difference. Quantify that. No difference in what your ears heard or no difference on the "S" meter. If the "S" meter reads the same on the dipole as on the 25' low wire, something is wrong. Check you coax connections. However, it's not unusual for a poor antenna to produe a similar "sounding" signal as a good antenna. Your dipole should be picking up more signal than the short wire, but it's also picking up more noise. So the "signal-to-noise ratio" your ears hear will often be the same. Did I waste my money on the Dipole antenna? I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. Now I'm wondering if the Dipole has any advantages over the long wire. Could some kind soul please explain what is happening? The trap dipole will have a predictable pattern on its resonant frequencies. A 200' wire will have different patterns on different frequencies (not necessarily a bad thing). I personally don't think it makes sense to spend a lot of money on a commercial trap dipole for SWL'ing. A random wire (doesn't have to be 200' long) is a very good choice. Signal-to-noise ratio is what determines readability, not absolute signal pickup. Art Harris N2AH |
If you don't mind the extra noise, I'd go with a longwire.
"Arthur Harris" wrote in message . net... "Lenny" wrote: I've had my R75 for about 2 years now. I purchased an Antenna Supermarket dipole, the one with the sealed traps, The traps make the dipole resonant at specific frequencies. On those frequencies the dipole will exhibit the normal broadside pattern. Trap dipoles tend to have narrow resonant bandwidths at the lower frequencies Last night was absolutely horrible for listening to foreign stations. Only received a few of the strongest ones that were beamed at N. America. Probably just propagation. I took a piece of speaker wire, about 25' long, twisted the 2 wires together at each end, stuck snip I switched back and forth from the wire to the dipole and no difference. Hmmmm, strange! I tuned in a few other stations that were weaker and again, no difference. Quantify that. No difference in what your ears heard or no difference on the "S" meter. If the "S" meter reads the same on the dipole as on the 25' low wire, something is wrong. Check you coax connections. However, it's not unusual for a poor antenna to produe a similar "sounding" signal as a good antenna. Your dipole should be picking up more signal than the short wire, but it's also picking up more noise. So the "signal-to-noise ratio" your ears hear will often be the same. Did I waste my money on the Dipole antenna? I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. Now I'm wondering if the Dipole has any advantages over the long wire. Could some kind soul please explain what is happening? The trap dipole will have a predictable pattern on its resonant frequencies. A 200' wire will have different patterns on different frequencies (not necessarily a bad thing). I personally don't think it makes sense to spend a lot of money on a commercial trap dipole for SWL'ing. A random wire (doesn't have to be 200' long) is a very good choice. Signal-to-noise ratio is what determines readability, not absolute signal pickup. Art Harris N2AH |
"Lenny" wrote in message ...
I've had my R75 for about 2 years now. I purchased an Antenna Supermarket dipole, the one with the sealed traps, for the radio. Then I went and had the Kiwa mods done. All in all, a very nice setup. And like everyone says, it's great at Utility listening. But lately, I've been wanting to dig out more of those tough foreign country broadcast signals. Last night was absolutely horrible for listening to foreign stations. Only received a few of the strongest ones that were beamed at N. America. So I figured I'd try something different. I took a piece of speaker wire, about 25' long, twisted the 2 wires together at each end, stuck one end into the R75 longwire input, and threw the rest out of my basement window (yes my radio is in the basement). So, I took the remaining 15 feet of wire and looped it into a bush along the side of my house. It must be all of 5' off the ground. Back inside I go, not expecting much from the wire. I tuned to a station I knew I could receive and voila! It came in nicely. I switched back and forth from the wire to the dipole and no difference. Hmmmm, strange! I tuned in a few other stations that were weaker and again, no difference. Amazing! Did I waste my money on the Dipole antenna? I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. Now I'm wondering if the Dipole has any advantages over the long wire. Could some kind soul please explain what is happening? Any recommendations? Is there a "SW Antennas for Dummies" site somewhere? Thank you, Lenny Several years ago I lived in Sacramento and put up the Sloper antenna - it was mounted on my tv antenna mast about 10-feet above roof level and ended on top of my 6-foot fence. I had is installed on my Grundig 650. It was professionally installed by an antenna dealer. On some frequencies, it did better than the internal whip antenna, and on other frequencies the internal whip did better. And on some frequencies the signal was the same. At no frequency did the Sloper antenna give a BIG difference in signal level compared to the internal whip, but on the tropical bands, it made enough of a difference to hear a couple stations that were hard to hear using the whip. But even then, on a slight difference. |
A longwire or inverted-L doesn't have to be noisier than balanced
antennas such as a dipole. It's matter of how the coax shield is grounded/decoupled from the antenna. Here's one way to do it: http://www.anarc.org/naswa/badx/ante...e_antenna.html Maximus wrote: If you don't mind the extra noise, I'd go with a longwire. "Arthur Harris" wrote in message . net... "Lenny" wrote: I've had my R75 for about 2 years now. I purchased an Antenna Supermarket dipole, the one with the sealed traps, The traps make the dipole resonant at specific frequencies. On those frequencies the dipole will exhibit the normal broadside pattern. Trap dipoles tend to have narrow resonant bandwidths at the lower frequencies Last night was absolutely horrible for listening to foreign stations. Only received a few of the strongest ones that were beamed at N. America. Probably just propagation. I took a piece of speaker wire, about 25' long, twisted the 2 wires together at each end, stuck snip I switched back and forth from the wire to the dipole and no difference. Hmmmm, strange! I tuned in a few other stations that were weaker and again, no difference. Quantify that. No difference in what your ears heard or no difference on the "S" meter. If the "S" meter reads the same on the dipole as on the 25' low wire, something is wrong. Check you coax connections. However, it's not unusual for a poor antenna to produe a similar "sounding" signal as a good antenna. Your dipole should be picking up more signal than the short wire, but it's also picking up more noise. So the "signal-to-noise ratio" your ears hear will often be the same. Did I waste my money on the Dipole antenna? I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. Now I'm wondering if the Dipole has any advantages over the long wire. Could some kind soul please explain what is happening? The trap dipole will have a predictable pattern on its resonant frequencies. A 200' wire will have different patterns on different frequencies (not necessarily a bad thing). I personally don't think it makes sense to spend a lot of money on a commercial trap dipole for SWL'ing. A random wire (doesn't have to be 200' long) is a very good choice. Signal-to-noise ratio is what determines readability, not absolute signal pickup. Art Harris N2AH -----= Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News =----- http://www.newsfeeds.com - The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! -----== Over 100,000 Newsgroups - 19 Different Servers! =----- |
I can't imagine what 200' of
wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. It would sound wondeful Lenny and cheap also.:-) Do it, you'll see what I mean. |
Several years ago I lived in Sacramento and put up the Sloper antenna
Huh? What 'kind' of sloper? I have the Alpha Delta DX sloper and if that's the one you're talking about, something isn't hooked up right if you're just getting those results. Just thought I'd throw that in the ring.:-) |
OK, good suggestions all.
Thanks. But more questions. If I connect the long wire to a coax feed, will it perform better than my Antenna Supermarket Dipole? And how does one connect a long wire to a coax? Lenny "Dxluver" wrote in message ... I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. It would sound wondeful Lenny and cheap also.:-) Do it, you'll see what I mean. |
And what's the best wire to use?
Braided or unbraided? Lenny "Dxluver" wrote in message ... I can't imagine what 200' of wire strung up 25' high in my trees will sound like. It would sound wondeful Lenny and cheap also.:-) Do it, you'll see what I mean. |
|
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:41 AM. |
|
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com