![]() |
Faraday Cage Grounded Or Ungrounded
I am assuming that a microwave oven is a Faraday cage. Since it keeps
the radiation trapped, bouncing around inside to heat up the food instead of you. I am betting you would loose signal on a cell phone completley if it were placed inside of a microwave with the door closed. This should work even with the oven unplugged from the wall outlet, which then would be ungrounded. The electric field inside a Faraday cage is zero, regardless of what the outside is doing or is connected to. But the reverse is also true. The charges that are built up from components inside of the Faraday cage are trapped to bounce around like the radiation inside of a microwave. So that makes me think it needs to be grounded. On the other hand, if the shell of a microwave is grounded. Then what keeps the radiation inside from going to ground instead of bouncing around and cooking your food? |
apples and oranges. the ( approx 1.2 cu ft ) metal space inside of a microwave oven is a " resonant " tuned circuit .... designed to resonate the microwave oscillator tube at it's designed operating freq. this tuned circuit impacts the total current drawn by the tube ( out of resonance will cause it to over heat ) ...... and promote power output into the load placed inside the " e " field of the microwave oven . grounded or not is not relevant ... except related to RF / emf interference related to the microwave RF signal or the power supply. spaces too large or too small would not work ... causing the tube to self destruct at worse and at the least preventing too little power to load ( flow ) into the space to cook anything. the microwave tube doesn't care about grounding ... it's all about size and shape to the tube. RF proof faraday shielded rooms ...... like the ones that used to be found in every hospital , back in the '50s , '60s and '70s ( tube type ekg diagnostic heart monitor machines used to be particularly susceptible to RF and EMF field interference ... this before the advent of " balanced " , common mode , noise canceling circuitry. ( found in ALL modern EKG machines ) are most definitely grounded to a earth ground where they are located. there used to be standards that the copper room shield grid had to have less than 1/4 to 1/2 of 1 ohm resistance between each copper shield plate and between those and ANY and every earth ground it was connected to. ( even the doorway and door had to be metal and had wires connecting them to the room walls ) these rooms are VERY RF proof and absolutely NO signals get into them or out of them . not am radio , not FM radio , not VHF handhelds and certainly not cellfones. the quality of the grounding , or said in another way , the lower the resistance between the shielding and the earth ground ... the more effective the shielded room works. EMF in particular , more than RF ..can penetrate the room more easily as the quality of the ground of the copped shield diminishes. 20 to 50 ohms between the shield and ground and you have a giant square , resonant RF antenna that picks up everything. these shielded rooms were necessary in the old days to insure the proper function of the ekg and eeg equipment ... no longer a problem with modern day circuit designs. these rooms have , for the most part, been disassembled and the huge amount of copper sold off for scrap. resonant cavities of microwave ovens ( the inside cooking space ) and faraday shielded rooms have practically NO technical commonality. apples and oranges .... k..................... I am assuming that a microwave oven is a Faraday cage. Since it keeps the radiation trapped, bouncing around inside to heat up the food instead of you. |
|
|
|
On Wed, 16 Jun 2004 14:50:47 -0500, AC/DC wrote
(in article ) : I am assuming that a microwave oven is a Faraday cage. Often attributed to Abraham Lincoln: question: How many legs does a dog have it we count the dog's tail as a leg? answer: Four. Caliing something by a name doesn't make it necessarily so. No, there is no Faraday cage inside a microwave oven anymore than coax is constructed of an inner wire, then physical insulation, then a Faraday cage, then the outer physical insulation. A microwave oven has shielding. Hopefully, enough shielding that it warms your coffee rather than you. Since it keeps the radiation trapped, bouncing around inside to heat up the food instead of you. I am betting you would loose signal on a cell phone completley if it were placed inside of a microwave with the door closed. This should work even with the oven unplugged from the wall outlet, which then would be ungrounded. Seems likely. But you could do the same thing with a big hunk of shielding from that coax we were using earlier. The electric field inside a Faraday cage is zero, regardless of what the outside is doing or is connected to. Not necessarily at all. A properly constructed Faraday cage (and they are simple and very easy to construct) has only the electrical/electronic field of any device within that generate something or atother. But the reverse is also true. The original wasn't true, either. The charges that are built up from components inside of the Faraday cage are trapped to bounce around like the radiation inside of a microwave. Do what? And to whom? And, "uh, eh, what?!?" ---- interrorbang There aren't any charges "built-up" inside a Faraday cage. It's not a capacitor, it's a blocktor -- joke on name. All five sides are tied together and well-grounded to dissipate the energy from both outside and inside. So that makes me think it needs to be grounded. On the other hand, if the shell of a microwave is grounded. Then what keeps the radiation inside from going to ground instead of bouncing around and cooking your food? The radiation of the klystron (or whatever is being used nowadays) radiates outward from the klystron. It strikes the coffee cup and permeates through to the coffee. It, then, follows the path of least resistance to the ground (because the definition of a ground is - yep, all that stuff, including that, also because . . . And stuff. And so forth.). I get the suspicious feeling (grin) that your "theory" abolishes the possibility of so-called "radio waves" ever having any useful purpose unless the xmtr and antenna aren't grounded. Gray Shockley -------------------------------------------------------- If you're aligning the first stage in a receiver and, at the same time, someone is working on a 2kw jammer in the same area, a Faraday Case could be an asset. |
On Wed, 16 Jun 2004 23:43:23 -0500, Beloved Leader wrote
(in article ) : (AC/DC) wrote in message . com... I am betting you would loose signal on a cell phone completley if it were placed inside of a microwave with the door closed. Coming soon: a mandatory federal label on a microwave oven stating: DO NOT OPERATE CELLPHONE WHILE INSIDE MICROWAVE OVEN "There are more people killed with unloaded microwave . . . . " |
On Thu, 17 Jun 2004 00:01:38 -0500, matt weber wrote
(in article ): On 16 Jun 2004 12:50:47 -0700, (AC/DC) wrote: I am assuming that a microwave oven is a Faraday cage. Since it keeps the radiation trapped, bouncing around inside to heat up the food instead of you. I am betting you would loose signal on a cell phone completley if it were placed inside of a microwave with the door closed. This should work even with the oven unplugged from the wall outlet, which then would be ungrounded. The electric field inside a Faraday cage is zero, regardless of what the outside is doing or is connected to. But the reverse is also true. The charges that are built up from components inside of the Faraday cage are trapped to bounce around like the radiation inside of a microwave. So that makes me think it needs to be grounded. On the other hand, if the shell of a microwave is grounded. Then what keeps the radiation inside from going to ground instead of bouncing around and cooking your food? It is better if the cage is grounded, but it doesn't have to be. Yeah, it pretty much does - results inside the cage could be questionable if it is not grounded, at least in the kc/mc freqs. However, realize that my example of the first stage in a receiver and a 2,000 watt jammer being worked on at the same time in the same room was /not/ a hypothetical but something I've had to deal with in both the U.S. and in Korea. The cage does have to be several skin thickness thick to be effective Additionally, it can have holes all over it (I know 25-40%). I've never used "solid" copper. however, Fortunate at Microwave oven frequencies, the skin depth is sub micron. without grounding the cage, it is possible for the cage to re-radiate some of the energy, but for the most part, the changing field are either reflected back into the chamber, or induce currents in the cage, which become I^r losses in the conductor the cage is made of. How much goes which way is a function of how good the conductor is, how thick it is, and the frequency of the field, the skin depth is zero, and field are 100% reflected. Okay. /gray/ |
Gray Shockley wrote:
"There are more people killed with unloaded microwave . . . . " Microwaves don't grill people. People grill people.. mike (...when they pry it from my cold, uncooked hands...) II |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:43 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
RadioBanter.com