Thread: BPL NPRM v. NOI
View Single Post
  #136   Report Post  
Old March 29th 04, 01:23 PM
Carl R. Stevenson
 
Posts: n/a
Default


"N2EY" wrote in message
...

Then there's the fact that the HF losses on power lines are so high that

BPL
systems need a repeater every few thousand feet. In rural areas that may

mean a
repeater for each customer, or more. Plus couplers and other hardware for
*each* customer.


The slides I've seen presented by BPL marketing fluff folks show repeaters
every
300 meters ... that's a hell of a lot of repeaters to "serve rural America"
.... yet they
claimed in the same presentation that it was "low cost because no
infrastructure was
required because the wires were already (presumably) there."

I pointed to their block diagrams with fiber to the area, "head-ends" to go
from fiber
to the MV/HV lines, repeaters every 300 meters, couplers, etc. and asked
"How can
you claim with a straight face that this "doesn't require the installation
of infrastructure?""

Carl - wk3c