"Bob Haberkost" wrote these clips:
The larger fields generated by the longer radiators makes
for more power transferred (which also explains why a taller
radiator has a higher intrinsic impedance,
Have to disagree with that. The reason that a 180 degree MW vertical
generates a stronger ground wave than a 90 degree vertical (other conditions
equal) is due SOLELY to the shape of their respective elevation patterns.
Their radiation efficiency or "power transferred" has nothing to do with
their base impedances.
If properly matched to their transmission lines, both of them radiate the
same total power. But the elevation pattern of the 180 degree radiator has
more intrinsic gain in the horizontal plane -- which produces the stronger
ground wave of the two.
so 1kW into a 90 degree stick will be about half as effective
as a 180 degree stick.)
Not following that conclusion. Using the FCC's numbers, a 180 degree MW
radiator with 1 kW input produces a groundwave field of 237 mV/m at one
mile, while a 90 degree radiator produces 190 mV/m. So for same input power
and other conditions, the 90 degree radiator produces 80% of the field
strength of the 180 degree radiator.
Put another way, the input power to the 90 degree radiator would have to be
increased about 1.56X in order to produce the same ground wave field at one
mile as the 180 degree radiator.
RF
|