View Single Post
  #21   Report Post  
Old December 8th 04, 11:20 PM
Twistedhed
 
Posts: n/a
Default

AKCM wrote:
Twist, states CAN make laws that are more


restrictive than federal law. What they cannot


do, is take away certain rights. Case in point:


It is legal to drink alcohol in public on Sunday


in the eyes of the feds. Some states say it is


illegal. And this is just one case, there are


many others. Where did you get this notion


that states laws cannot be more restrictive?



I said no such thing. State law can always be more restrictive than
federal law, but it may never permit what federal law restricts. I said
federal law always supercedes state law. If a state law permits it,
(such as medicinal pot) and the federal law restricts it (such as
telephone tampering and wiretapping), the federal law wins every time,
unless, of course, a state chooses to secede and avail itself of all
federal monies and benefits it receives.