On Tue, 19 Oct 2004 10:03:10 -0700, "Chuck"
wrote:

I have for a long time, suspected there
was a tx line modeling problem in NEC.
Now, it is apparent this problem exists
only in your EZNEC.


Hi Chuck,

You asked how to avoid this (if indeed it exists), and I offered a
very simple response to which you have had no comment. You continue
this "claim" of a problem and yet with very simple modeling
alternatives to prove it (aside from testimonials) you have yet to
achieve this proof or demonstrate you have even attempted a
resolution. Is this because it is not in your interest?

Roy has offered a means to have a third party verify your claims,
independent of his software such that it comes down to you are right,
or he is right. You have not taken this offer either and it seems,
given the expense, you either cannot afford to be right (which would
be fully funded by Roy) or you cannot afford to be wrong (which would
be fully funded by you). Any "expense" grievance leans towards the
second interpretation.

You also had another offer to range test, but I can full well
appreciate your backing off from that in overdrive. Any such offers
should be closely attended by "Who owns the intellectual rights to the
results?" If you claimed X gain and the test demonstrated X+1 results
because of "simple adjustments" at the site, "Who owns the
intellectual rights to the results AND the "new" antenna?" If you
attempted to publish the results (assuming they were complementary)
would you be threatened with plagiarism and copyright violation?

Answers to these questions may be researched at the Google Archives by
simply entering the search terms of "Patent Pending," "you may be
sued," "my lawyer will contact your lawyer," "intellectual property."
Once you use any one of these phrases (or all of them - it constitutes
one of our best Soap Operas), simply sort on the basis of author hits
to see who holds the record for these issues as a business manifesto.

It won't be Roy.

There seem to be solutions in the queue, what remains to be seen is if
one or several are visited, or if future communication will be stuck
in the groove of repetition and denial.

73's
Richard Clark, KB7QHC