Reg Edwards wrote:
So your argument, whatever it is, falls as flat as a pancake on Good Friday.

I am assuming lossy lines, where R G, as is typical of transmission
lines used at HF frequencies. So exactly where does my argument fall flat?

Actually, it seems that it is your argument that is falling flat as R is
rarely, if ever, equal to G at HF frequencies. Where would we ever obtain
such a terrible dielectric at HF that G would be equal to R? Maybe 9913
filled with water?
--
73, Cecil, W5DXP