I dont think so...he waited too long. And if dropped during that time
or even during shipping, you could only know if he'd checked it right
away. Which normally understood, a week , yeah, , 4 mos, hah!! On
the other hand, if he whines real loudly and you do much trading, its
worth it to shut him up...hard scenario though...everybody gets to be
right and wrong .....maybe send half if he send the filter?

hobbes wrote:
To the Group:

Please consider the following scenario. Back in October 2004 a person
places an ad in "rec.radio.swap" looking for a filter for his Ten Tec radio.
I have such a working filter that is surplus to my needs since I sold a Ten
Tec radio some two weeks earlier to an individual who did not want the
filter. I respond to the individual looking for the filter that I want $65
for the filter and shipping. He sends me a postal money order, I send him
filter, and I hear nothing.

Yesterday, February 25, 2005, some four months later, I receive an e-mail
from the individual who purchased the filter advising me that the filter is
dead. According to him, he never used the filter, but he had a freiend
install the filter in a radio and found it to be dead.

Question - The filter was working when I removed it from my radio and
subsequently sent it to him. Shouldn't he have advised me shortly after he
received the filter that it did not work? I have no way of telling whether
the filter was mishandled or installed improperly. If you were me would you
return the money he paid for his purchase some four months earlier.

Thanks for reading this post.

Hobbes