Radiation Resistance
Roy, W7EL wrote:
"Do the proper substitutionn and you`ll get the correct answer."
Yes. The warning also appears on page 137:
"In developing the field expressions for the short dipole, which were
used in obtaining (5-56), (5-56) is the value of radiation resistance,
the restriction was made that lambda is much larger than the length of
the dipole L." No problem there, Reg specified a short monopole.
Kraus does a sample calculation for a short dipole. I used Kraus` data
and got the same answer when duplicating his calculation.
But Reg was not asking for an answer to a specific problem. Reg was
asking for the value of the constant in a formula of the same form.
Kraus gives it as 80 pi squared for a dipole.. This is 790.
We know that a monopole has half the resistance of a dipole. Example: 73
ohms and 36.5 ohms. 790 / 2 = 395. That`s not a resistance, it is only
the value of a constant which must be multiplied by (L/lambda) squared
to give the radiation resistance of a very short monopole.
Best regards, Richard Harrison, KB5WZI
|