Tom Donaly wrote:
I never for a moment, though,
thought there was anything wrong with your understanding.

Tom, are you retracting what you posted? If so, just come right out
and say so. Otherwise, you are going to have to live with the reality
that what you posted agrees with my side of the argument and disagrees
with W8JI and W7EL. Both of you guys say there is no phase information
left in the measured phase of the standing wave current. Do you wish
to retract your statements? Since W7EL measured the phase of the
standing wave current and drew illogical conclusions from that
measurement, are you guys going to support W7EL's conclusion or
support the technical facts that you posted previously? Please choose.

Seems to me you are caught between supporting the irrationality of
a friend or the laws of physics. Please choose the technically
correct side. Ham Radio will be better served by that decision.
--
73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp