Richard Clark wrote:

On Fri, 19 May 2006 15:08:11 GMT, "Tom Donaly"
wrote:


Stokes' law and the Raman effect can be found in
physics texts dealing with quantum mechanics. Georg Joos, in
his book _Theoretical Physics_ deals with such things. The reading
is dense but the underlying concepts aren't too difficult. The
difficulty might lie in understanding how they apply to this
discussion.


Hi Tom,

Certainly Joos would give some entry into the field, but finding work
as accessible outside of a bookstore or library (in other words,
through a search engine) makes for drinking out of a fire hose to
quench a sip's worth of thirst.

Insofar as HOW this applies, I've spoken to that and Tom shows
interest. That alone goes beyond the typical churning that passes for
discussion. The point is that these underlying concepts are fairly
simple as you imply and they are certainly not remote from the usual
topics of consideration here. What they lack is specifics that relate
to our common applications, and there too I've offered discussion.
However, few seem inspired to travel those paths and that fault can
hardly be laid at my doorstep.

73's
Richard Clark, KB7QHC

Hi Richard,
I didn't intend any criticism. People like Cecil, with
home-grown theories, don't ever seem to want things considered in
depth. That's understandable from a psychological standpoint, but
it isn't any help to the rest of us when some of the things the theory
ignores become significant. In the case of antennas, practically
everything is significant.
73,
Tom Donaly, KA6RUH