RadioBanter - View Single Post

June 24th 06, 02:00 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna

wrote:
Cecil Moore wrote:
As you are doing, I could cut and paste your postings to make you
seem ignorant and insane. But only an unethical person does that.

Then you are also unethical, because if you look back that is EXACTLY
what you do to others.

It is my custom to trim out the part of postings with which I
agree and respond to the part with which I disagree. I believe
that is in accordance with the newsgroup guidelines. I do not,
as you do, cut and paste to completely change the meaning of
what was previously posted so you can attack a straw man of
your own creation.

Your latest posting, where you take my mental exercise example
of a hypothetical antenna with a hypothetical highly charged
particle hitting it to try to prove that I said each real world
particle causes noise that can be heard in a receiver is really,
really lame.

That is why Roy and others have you in a "Cecil filter".

Roy ploinked me because I said an antenna is a distributed network.
I thought he had previously said an antenna was a lumped circuit.
Instead of telling me that's not what he meant and giving me a chance
to apologize, he ploinked me.

When you are willing to rationally discuss those hypothetical
examples I have posted, let me know.
--
73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp