RadioBanter - View Single Post

Cecil Moore · July 16th 06, 03:51 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna

wrote:
You interact with others through obfuscation and bullying.

I treat others the way they treat me. I treat you the way
you treat me. You insist on turning my inclusive statements
into exclusive straw men statements so you can argue with
them. You are the only one who can change that interaction.
We just had a civil exchange over on QRZ.COM where you didn't
misquote me for a change. That could happen here.

No designer in his right mind would use such a lousy feed system to
feed a pattern sensitive design like a Yagi antenna, they are barely
acceptable as a omni-antenna.

I agree with everything you said about J-Poles in this posting
so you are apparently trying to set up yet another straw man.
One wonders why you feel compelled to try such a transparent
trick. When I disagree with you on one minor point, you react
as if I had disagreed with you on all major points. You really
need to learn the difference between "inclusive" and "exclusive".
My disagreement was inclusive of your point 1, not with anything
else you said. That's why I trimmed out everything else.

What I disagreed with you on is that common-mode current is
the same at two different points in a J-Pole system separated
by a 1/4WL stub feed system.
--
73, Cecil http://www.qsl.net/w5dxp