Cecil Moore wrote:
Jim Kelley wrote:

You should think about it because amateur radios don't usually have
circulators on their output, and the result illuminates a corner of
the discussion that you've been pretty closed minded about.


Here's a brainteaser for you, Jim. Assume the following example
under steady-state conditions:



XMTR--X--tuner--Y--one second long lossless feedline---291.42 ohms
Ps=100W Pfor=200W-- --100W=Pref PL=100W

If you aren't going to solve the problem I posed, then I don't see why
I should feel obliged to bother with any more of yours. Only seems
fair. There is a significant point to my question that you still
have not addressed. Would you have us believe that some new
revelation is being presented by this latest problem of yours? Or
perhaps it's simply intended to divert attention away, once again,
from my question.

Or maybe it was just too hard for you. How about a simpler problem then:

XMTR--X--one second long lossless feedline---infinite ohms
PS=100W

How many Joules are stored in the transmission line? Why?

73, ac6xg