Thread: Rhombics
View Single Post
  #36   Report Post  
Old October 1st 06, 11:27 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
Roy Lewallen Roy Lewallen is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,374
Default Rhombics

Richard Fry wrote:

AFAIK, neither NEC 2 nor NEC 4 from any source will show a composite
elevation pattern over a defined ground at a specified distance to
include the space wave and the surface wave in a single display. One
must merge them using his/her own understanding and resources.


Neither NEC-2 nor NEC-4 shows a display of any kind. Output is solely in
the form of tables of numbers. Surface wave data, when produced, is
always combined with the sky wave as a total field value. It's chosen
with an option on the RP input "card". The NEC-2 manual as well as NEC-2
itself -- including source code which enables you to see exactly how the
calculations are done -- are freely available on the Internet. So
there's no need to speculate about what it does or doesn't do.

EZNEC demo, standard, and plus program types don't include the surface
wave in far field outputs, which as I explained in an earlier posting in
another thread(*), isn't of much practical use to most amateurs.
However, when needed the data can be obtained from the near field
analysis (which is actually a total field analysis and isn't restricted
to the near field). EZNEC pro program types (EZNEC-M and EZNEC/4) allow
direct inclusion of the surface wave in the far field analysis, mostly
for the use of AM broadcast consultant customers. It provides tabular
and graphical outputs in the form of an azimuth plot at any desired
horizontal distance from the antenna and height above ground. Like NEC,
the output is the total field, or in other words the sum of surface and
sky wave, and the results should be virtually identical to those from NEC.

(*) I recommend that anyone interested in this topic read the posting I
made just a few days ago, Sept. 28, on this newsgroup under the thread
"Elevation Patterns of Ground Mounted Vertical Monopoles". It can easily
be located at http://groups.google.com if it's not still on your
newsreader client.

Roy Lewallen, W7EL