On Fri, 13 Oct 2006 19:45:56 -0800, "Dana"
wrote:


It's not my issue to claim detection of different devices
proves detection of an MP3 player recording.

I never said it can detect an MP3 player recording.
I said it can detect an MP3 player, or pretty much anything electronic.


The thread is about detecting an MP3 player. Show us it can
be done, regardless of whether recording or not. It would
have to be discriminated from other devices, and DEPENDING
ON SCENARIO, from a fair distance and continuously, else the
person carrying it just turns it on when needed.




We have no reason to believe a scenario like the OP has (too
vaguely) posed,

Actually what he needs is a device to scan for electronic devices, and they
exist already. How the OP handles the knowledge of such sweeps depends on
him.


I have never claimed "electronic devices" can't be detected.
It's not enough, electronic devices are everywhere! It'll
have to discriminate, unless you're in a 3rd world country
where they can just go ahead and shoot anyone they suspect-
so there was no need for a scanner at all.