View Single Post
  #14   Report Post  
Old October 26th 06, 03:32 AM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
jawod jawod is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 303
Default Hf Antenna Question - so what's the conclusion?

Dave wrote:
wrote:

Ian White (GM3SEK), Cecil Moore (W5DXP), and probably others have
discused HF chokes made from flat vs. bunched coils of coaxial cable,
but I must have missed some posting(s), for I haven't recognized
anything that looks like a CONCLUSION.

* Is "bunched" or "flat" better?
* Are they basically single-band or wide-band or somewhere in-between?
* Are there "rules of thumb" to make them for hams with
* No test equipment?
* A grid-dip meter?
* A noise bridge?
* An antenna analyzer?


Conclusions! You want WHAT??

You have recognized a GREAT TRUTH about this group. There NEVER is a
conclusion! Oh, there are subthreads, red herring threads, three month
continuous running threads, insulting threads, I am better than you are
threads, even threads that remain close to the original subject.

But, there is NEVER a concluding post to a thread.

You need to do some reading. Try "Conclusions for Dummies", along with
Feynman's "Special Relativity and the Dipole" and possibly also "String
Theory and Its Applications to Near Field Anomalies". After that, you
have my permission to post in this NG.