View Single Post
  #20   Report Post  
Old February 7th 07, 01:36 AM posted to rec.radio.amateur.policy
Stefan Wolfe Stefan Wolfe is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Dec 2006
Posts: 179
Default Did this Amateur Violate US Neutrality Act?


wrote in message
...
Stefan Wolfe wrote:

"KC4UAI" wrote in message
ups.com...
On Feb 5, 9:53 pm, "Stefan Wolfe" wrote:
"KC4UAI" wrote in message

ups.com...

On Feb 2, 9:20 pm, "Stefan Wolfe" wrote:
And is it legal for a licensed amateur to violate rules of a
sovereign
country (no matter how well-intentioned?

Um...

Until this guy gets convicted of a crime in the US, the FCC won't
have
much to say...

So, are you saying he violated US law? If not then what's the
point?

The US Government tends to frown on US citizens providing material
support
snip

Then, get the guy convicted of a crime and *then* complain to the FCC
about his license... The FCC is not in the business of enforcing all
the laws of the US, just the ones they wrote.


If it involves illegal transmission by a US citizen or resident of
electromagnetic waves anywhere, between 3000Hz and light waves, it is
within
the FCC's scope to take action.


If the action violates US law and occured on US soil, the FCC can take
action.

If not, the foreign government can prosecute if the offender is on their
soil, or if not and there is a treaty, ask the US for extradition of the
offender, none of which would involve the FCC.

The FCC has no jurisdiction over anything that happens on foreign soil.

The FCC could take action after the person was convicted by a foreign
government under the various character clauses.


On more than one occasion, shortwave pirate broadcasters have taken their
radio equipment onto to a ship, sailed out to international waters and
transmitted. In every case, when the ship returned to USA waters, the FCC
seized their equipment and prosecuted the pirate broadcasters.

The offenses did not occur on USA territory.

The FCC acted in accordance with treaties signed by the USA and other ITU
members.

QED.