Owen Duffy wrote:

Dan Bloomquist wrote in news:4khKh.5006$ya1.3770
@news02.roc.ny:


Owen Duffy wrote:


Dan Bloomquist wrote in
:



Are the principles that apply to this example inconsistent with the
general case (eg dc, ac, transient, steady state etc)?

Yes.


I would have thought the answer was NO, the principles are *not*
inconsistent with the general case.

Hi Owen,
See the example I posted where a pulse is sent down the line. In that
case all the energy is dissipated in the source resistor.


Dan, I don't deny there may be cases where that may happen, but it is not
true that reflected power is necessarily dissipated (or partly
dissipated) in the equivalent source resistance.

And I answered accordingly when you asked the very question, I agreed
with you. And I showed just that in the step example of a previous post.

Owen

Best, Dan.