On Apr 18, 8:57 am, Cecil Moore wrote:
Keith Dysart wrote:
Some may argue that a perfect generator can not be constructed, but
really that is a matter of cash; with enough cash one can construct
a generator that is arbitrarily close to perfect.

But bears no resemblance to the average amateur radio
transmitter. The *goal* is to explain what happens with
the average amateur radio transmitter. We already have
signal generators with circulator loads that will do
what you are trying to do. So why bother trying to
reinvent the wheel?

You give yourself the perfect out, don't you. You won't study
the simple circuits that can be understand (for which, by the
way a circulator is not required, thus indicating that you do not
yet understand them) because they are not complicated
enough to represent an average amateur radio transmitter, and
you can't study an average amateur radio transmitter because it
is too complicated to be understood.

Conclusion: No need to study. Life is good. No need to understand.

So sad.

....Keith