K7ITM wrote:
To me, the whole idea of using phasors is to remove the time-varying
quantity from discussion, so you can concentrate on phase and
magnitude.
Yes, that was what I was doing. I think that is what EZNEC
does. I think that is what Kraus does. It seems to be the
key in determining what phase shift occurs through a 75m
loading coil.
Incidentally, one of the best treatments of this subject,
IMO, is in "Optics", by Hecht.
I suppose I get a little carried away on things like this, but to me
it's important that we're communicating with words for which we share
a single definition, not words that mean distinctly different things
to different people.
Apparently, someone needs to get carried away in order to
get this problem resolved. A measured zero phase shift
through a loading coil using a current that doesn't change
phase is meaningless and misleading.
--
73, Cecil
http://www.w5dxp.com