Cecil Moore wrote:
Jim Kelley wrote:

It was my contention then that the IEEE did not support such a view,
and that remains my view.


Do you support the IEEE's contention that
"power propagates in a wave"? It's a simple
yes/no question, Jim.

Your question is based on an incorrect assumption, Cecil. As you are
well aware, a correct answer cannot be given to such a question. As
far as I know, you're the only one who derives that particular meaning
from that particular IEEE definition. So unless you can get the
person who wrote the definition to confirm your belief, the dispute at
this point would appear to be between you and him. A more reasonable
point of view would be that IEEE is simply defining the Poynting
Vector. If that puts me between a rock and a hard place then I guess
that's something I'll just have to bear. :-)

73, AC6XG