Identify unknown signal or modulation mode commonly heard in the 1960s
			 
			 
			
		
		
		
			
			 
"msg"  wrote in message 
... 
 Greetings: 
 
 Seeking opinions on an old, commonly heard signal (AM) on HF, of some 
 considerable power, with a very memorable sound. 
 
 This will be a bit difficult to describe and I wonder if some folks 
 would have audio recordings of spectrum surveillance from the 1960s 
 for an actual sample, but in lieu of that I will try to convey a 
 sense of what it was.  I had always assumed that it was photo 
 transmissions by the wire services, but listening to modern equivalents 
 I have doubts; it actually sounds more like the early telephone 
 voice scrambling systems that were acoustically coupled to the handset, 
 and which produced a continuous noise irrespective of voice level. 
 The sound on the air was much like hearing several P51 fighters 
 approaching at high airspeed and props not in phase; the spectral 
 power is mostly in the range of about 200 Hz to 500 Hz with a 
 varying heterodyne of several Hz. It had a bandwidth of at least 
 25 kHz (can't say more precisely due to the cheap receivers I had at 
 the time).  I don't remember the frequencies, but at the time I would 
 have been concentrating on monitoring 3 Mhz to about 12 Mhz, and these 
 signals were strong at all hours on perhaps a dozen different frequencies. 
 I always regarded them as annoying QRM. 
 
 I did little SWLing from the mid '70s until somewhat recently, and of 
 course there is nothing like this heard nowadays. 
 
 At the time, my QTH was about 25 miles from the largest National Guard 
 training camp in the midwest and there were four USAF bases within 200 
 miles 
 as well, so it could well have been some modulation mode used by the 
 military. 
 
 I would really enjoy knowing if others remember a signal like this 
 and knew its origins. 
 
 Regards, 
 
 Michael 
 
I remember what you are talking about.  When I was 
a preteen in the late 60's using a cheap shortwave 
receiver we heard things such that we naturally said, 
"That sounds like an airplane."  Sounded like someone 
left the mike open in the cockpit of an airplane.  We 
suspected that they probably weren't airplanes because 
there never was a voice and who would just transmit 
airplane noise. 
 
Most likely they were, as others have said, VFT or 
something like it.  They were almost certainly a 
Frequency Division Multiplexing or Frequency Diversity 
system, i.e. multiple carriers stacked in frequency, 
each modulated (with either PSK or FSK) and 
shifted in time relative to each other.  The diversity 
is usefull against the frequency selective multipath 
fading of HF propagation.  If multipath causes 
a dropout of one carrier the info is still available 
in the other carriers. 
I'm a little surprised to think they had that technology 
back then but maybe I shouldn't be. 
 
Ionospheric multipath fading can also give it 
a doppler-like sound, as if it were airplanes diving 
and banking. 
 
You can sometimes hear signals like you describe 
today.  There is something like it now at 
11455 kHz, s5, 04:55 utc, in socal. 
 
I hear VFT at 11010.55 and 11499 kHz 
occasionally. 
I have demodulated them down to bits and then 
run autocorrelations.  The autocorrelations were 
flat indicating that they are encrypted. 
 
There are many utes using OFDM these days. 
They sound similar but sound more flat, 
more whitenoise-like.  I've heard them at: 
4.28480 
4.5905 
4.81020 
5.0175 
6.39250 
6.39850 
6.42320 
6.4345 
6.76525 
6.84272 
8.4884 
8.541 
8.553 
8.6255 
8.646 
12.7243 
12.805 
13.41050 
16.9435 
17.07750 
17.08250 
17.098 
 
all in MHz, all USB. 
 
If you find any old recordings I'd be interested in 
hearing them too. 
 
-- 
rb 
 
 
 
 
		 
		
		
		
		
		
		
		
		
	
	 |