"james" wrote in message...

Brian

Here is the jeopardy question for you:

In the category of electronics for $100

Name the only signal that has the same value for its peak
and average value?

If he doesn't, does the question get thrown open to the
opposing team for a bonus point?
Oh, wait a minute... you are the opposing team :~)

Now if you can answer that correctly, then you will understand
why a modulating signal that yields both 100% modulation on
its peak and its average is unitelligable.

Even if he gets it, do you think that it's in his favor to accept
the facts? His only product would become pointless, and any
money and time invested will be lost.


If you answer that then we might go onto electronics for $200.

The problem is that this subject involves more than
electronics. Human speech, hearing and interpretation
is much more than simple decibel level.

Do you really have the spare time to explain everything
to him? If so, do you really want to be faced with legal
action when his brain implodes?


Regards,
Peter.