On Nov 16, 3:10 pm, Cecil Moore wrote:
K7ITM wrote:
Nice "when are you going to stop beating your mother" sort of
question. And what was your reply?

It's a rhetorical question, Tom. What is your reply?
When someone (besides Eugene Hecht) explains it to
my satisfaction I will stop beating that dead horse.
--
73, Cecil http://www.w5dxp.com

From your original posting, "The following is from an email to which I
replied today." There was no indication than anything following that
was your reply, and I was curious what your reply was. You're welcome
to beat dead horses as much as you like, but that doesn't mean I need
to.

Assuming the two "waves" existed independently at some points in
space, you'll have to first tell us _exactly_ what was done to combine
them into one wave. Right now I'm not accepting that you will be able
to combine two independent waves carrying 50 watts each into a single
wave carrying more than 100 watts. Thus, it's a "when are you going
to stop beating your mother" problem, as posed. There's really
nothing interesting except at the point at which the waves combine.
But then that's already been explained more than once.