Cecil Moore wrote:
Gene Fuller wrote:
Waves are useful. However, they are not living objects. They have no
will to survive. There is nothing in the standard E&M science based on
Maxwell's laws that requires waves to be "canceled" if they no longer
exist. There is no conservation law of wave-ality.

All EM waves must obey the conservation of energy and
conservation of momentum principles. It is not a will
to survive - it is simply the laws of physics.

Here is an example for you to explain. The source is
a signal generator equipped with an ideal circulator
and a load resistor:

Steady-state #1: Rho at '+' equals 0.7143. Load equals
300 ohms.

100w SGCL--50 ohm feedline--+--1/2WL 300 ohm feedline--300 ohm load
Pfor1=100w-- Pfor2=49w--
--Pref1=51w --Pref2=0w

Pref1 is an 51w EM wave whose energy and momentum must be
conserved.

Steady-state #2: Rho at '+' equals 0.7143. Load is switched
to 50 ohms.

100w SGCL--50 ohm feedline--+--1/2WL 300 ohm feedline--50 ohm load
Pfor1=100w-- Pfor2=204W--
--Pref1=0w --Pref2=104w

*Note that Rho has NOT changed!*

The only question that you need to answer is during the
process that changes Pref1 from 51 joules/sec in the direction
of the source to 0 joules/sec (canceled), *exactly* what happens
to the energy and momentum? Please be specific.


Cecil,

Nice try.

Combining "steady state" with "switched" and "during the process that
changes" makes a very messy problem for an analytical solution.

You first.

And you won't get any closer to the correct solution through all of your
handwaving arguments either.

73,
Gene
W4SZ