On Tue, 04 Dec 2007 00:31:02 GMT, Cecil Moore
wrote:

I apologize, Richard, like W8JI, I am unwilling to cut my
75m Texas bugcatcher coil in half. But then, his coil didn't
cost $180 either. :-)

The experiment that you are suggesting is exactly the same
that I suggested to W8JI but he was unwilling to perform
such and I tend to understood why. :-)

As a data point, in the previous argument a couple of years
ago, W8JI tried to use the lumped inductance feature of EZNEC
to "prove" there is never any phase shift through any coil. :-)

So, the short of it (the long of it is above) is that neither of you
have valid data that demonstrates a Corum solution. I'm not
surprised.

Seeing that there is no valid conclusion, it must be by the extended
logic of your understanding of English that both your and Tom's
positions are thus INVALID.

Anything left to introduce, barring actual test results, is not
superposition, but supposition.