On 17 Jan, 15:31, Cecil Moore wrote:
art wrote:
I decided to dumb it down and refer only to particles. Later I was
forced to move up to electrons because of counter posting. If I was to
move now up to protons when the group does not understand electrons or
even the common parallel circuit I think I would then parallel your
situation where you refuse to dummy down to reflect the audience.

There are a host of applications that simply cannot be dummied
down to the lumped circuit level. I am unable to teach my dog
to look at the clock and tell whether it is dinnertime or not.
Is that my fault or hers? The answer is more complicated than
one might think at first glance.
--
73, Cecil *http://www.w5dxp.com
Cecil,
I respectfully do not agree with that.I would suggest that the antenna
mechanics what I am preaching is directly applicable to complex
circuitry.If antenna theory can't
apply to such then the theory is in error.Antenna radiation came to a
halt in understanding some 50+ years ago.Since then science have tried
a lot of new sciences that even tho they do not solve the mystery of
radiation provides a whole new stream of old wives tales.And hams are
sucking every thing up without question. Nature has simple habits , it
is humans that try to make it complicated.
My best regards
Art Unwin KB9MZ...XG (uk)