Cecil Moore wrote:
Keith Dysart wrote:
On Mar 4, 10:25 pm, Cecil Moore wrote:
Nobody has ever claimed that the energy/power
analysis applies to instantaneous values.

Are you saying that conservation of energy does NOT apply to
instantaneous values?

Of course not. I am saying that the 50 watts in the
source resistor power equation is an average power.
It is invalid to try to add instantaneous power to
an average power, as you tried to do.

The
energy/power values are all based on RMS voltages
and currents. There is no such thing as an
instantaneous RMS value.

I understand the analysis technique you are proposing. That
it leads to the wrong conclusion can be easily seen when the
instantaneous energy flows are studied. This merely demonstrates
that the analysis technique has its limitations.

The proposed analysis technique is a tool. Trying to apply
that tool to instantaneous powers is like trying to use a
DC ohm-meter to measure the feedpoint impedance of an antenna.
Only a fool would attempt such a thing.

The bottom line remains that the reflected energy is not
dissipated in the source resistor, even for the special cases
under discussion.

Saying it doesn't make it so, Keith. There is nothing to
keep the reflected energy from being dissipated in the
source resistor.

If the reflected energy is not dissipated in the source
resistor, where does it go? Please be specific because it
is obvious to me that there is nowhere else for it to go
in the special zero interference case presented.

Here are some of your choices:

1. Reflected energy flows through the resistor and into
the ground without being dissipated.

2. The 50 ohm resistor re-reflects the reflected energy
back toward the load. (Please explain how a 50 ohm load
on 50 ohm coax can cause a reflection.)

3. There's no such thing as reflected energy.

4. Reflected waves exist without energy.

5. ______________________________________________.


Gentlemen;

What I was taught long ago was that the phenomenon that we call
reflected energy is radiated on the return. That portion of energy that
is not radiated is re-reflected and is radiated. This continues until
the level of energy no longer supports radiation. Resistance also
dissipates a portion of the transmitted energy. That resistance includes
the resistor under discussion above and that resistance found in the
coax conductors.

Of course my Elmer could have been wrong.


Dave WD9BDZ