The Rest of the Story
On Apr 13, 9:45*am, Cecil Moore wrote:
Keith Dysart wrote:
For the specific situation you describe above:
"energy flowing out of both ends at the same time"
means that the energy stored in the ooil is being
reduced to supply the energy leaving the top and
the bottom. The sum of the energy flows out of
the top and the bottom is exactly equal to the rate
at which the stored energy is being reduced.
Yes, the energy obviously balances but the instantaneous
powers are in opposite directions and therefore cannot
balance.
Lumped or not lumped is moot.
Energy cannot flow out of both ends of a lumped circuit
inductor. The current is, by definition, exactly the
same at both ends as it is for the lumped inductors in
EZNEC. You might find these class notes informative.
It is well known that if one builds the wrong model one
will get the wrong answer. You build the wrong model,
then claim that flows do not balance. Unbalanced flows
are the expected result from incomplete models.
Your imcompleteness is that you forgot to include the
energy flow into the electric and magnetic fields around
the coil. When one does not forget this flow, all of
the flows will balance at every instant.
...Keith
|