View Single Post
  #21   Report Post  
Old May 11th 08, 08:03 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
ml ml is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 225
Default Palstar ZM30 or Kuranishi BR-210

In article ,
"Andy" wrote:

I want to buy an antenna analyzer and have narrowed it down to two.



What is the best one to buy from these two, Palstar ZM30 or Kuranishi BR-210
and why?



What are the pro's and con's between these two, if any?



Thanks


hi

there are a few good analizers out there assuming you are looking at
hf frequencies,

timewave makes anice unit, as does autek

mfj as mentioned here does some nice stuff

it was a tough choice for me not to many units but they are mostly
simular features depending on the type of work you need to do one
feature vs another might make a buying point with you

however i ended up w/the aea hf analysist, i got it mostly because
it could be run on batteries or adapter could be connected to a
computer after measurements to analyze data OR be connected to pc
for simutenious readouts

it was very rugged case lookes like it was ment to be dropped and
live membrane keypad so a little water mist /dust/dirt won't
gum it up

was very easy to use had both digital and graphical readouts and
the readouts were real time so i can just watch the meater and prune
/adjust antenna

aea gave me good support

thats just my 2cents i really like the timewave i just couldn't
afford it at the time but would consider one , one day never ever
saw one used.

i think the mfj are prob the lowest cost units i forgot which
but arrl recently did a shootout of the analyzers goto the arrl web
site and search the ast article their comparisons fo all the units
were really nice

if you don't need a portable unit visit arraysolutions.com they
mike a nice vector analyer that is great youll need a pc laptop to
use portabloe


good luck