On Tue, 31 Mar 2009 20:13:36 GMT, Owen Duffy wrote:

Owen Duffy wrote in
:

...
I have been quiet here, but have been modelling and writing notes up
on the results. I have asked for comment on a draft model, and subject
to that, I will post the URL for further comments, hopefully in a day
or two.

http://www.vk1od.net/antenna/ccps/index.htm

Owen

Hi Owen,

This is a lot to digest at this time, but at least it is all in one
place and done well.

You offer several many solutions (to what are arguably straw men
hypothesis such as the W5GI mystery antenna) and there are certainly
gaps that beg filling: Fig. 2 is rather anemic as is the original
supporting commentary.

I offered a comment long ago that my best guess was that phasing would
seem to separate your two examples. That seems to have been both
vindicated and rejected through the numerous examples - I've lost
track of the focus.

I will have to revisit the comments in this thread and tie them to the
cogent points of your page.

73's
Richard Clark, KB7QHC