"Art Unwin" wrote in message
...
EZNEC and the Cecil-Corum method are in agreement.
Correct

if you had stopped there i would have commended you on another correct
response... but you just couldn't, could you???

but the solution is in error as equilibrium demands that the
radiator is in equilibrium ie equal to a period or multiples there of.

you never have defined equilibrium or shown where it is a requirement on
maxwell's equations. i have stated that maxwell's equations rely on NOT
being in equilibrium since they describe fields and waves that can vary in
time, hence they are not in equilibrium with anything. keep going art,
always fun reading!