RadioBanter - View Single Post - Dual-Z0 Stubs

Jim Kelley · May 8th 09, 08:21 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna

wrote:
Still here, and still trying to strip away the personal attacks to try
to understand the various underlying technical opinions!

Same here.

2) Jim, Tom, Roy (and any others): It appears you think the Corum
model is flawed, or not appropriate to the "bugcatcher".

For me, it's the latter.

What I've not
yet understood is what alternative model you are advocating which
would match the EZNEC results more closely than the Corum model. I've
heard at least Roy say that a lumped-inductor model is inappropriate,
but I don't think I've yet heard any other model proposed. Perhaps I
missed it?

Regards,
Steve G3TXQ

Hi Steve,

Personally, I think some actual measurements would help enormously in
formulating/evaluating a model. Otherwise all we have is hand waving
and proselytizing.

73, ac6xg