"Richard Clark" wrote
news
On Sat, 30 May 2009 18:43:45 +0200, Szczepan Bia?ek
wrote:
"Dave" wrote
.. .
both, and neither,
which part radiate the radio waves.

I can see a struggle developing here between you and Art as to who has
the claim to wear the cap and bells.

Dale wrote " Neither seems to have an interest in real world antennas. "

I have "an interest in real world antennas. " But only in the fundamental
evidences of wave propagation.
I am not preparing the new theory. The Your engineering theory suits me.
That from physics textbooks not.
In physics is the hydraulic analogy. It is usefull for DC. For high
frequences not. But Maxwell PROPOSED such model for HF.
After his death the electrons vere discovered. So Maxwell did not create
equations for electrons. Engineers use the empirical ones.
S*