On Jan 9, 11:33*am, Dave wrote:
On Jan 9, 5:27*pm, Dave wrote:

On Jan 9, 4:19*pm, Art Unwin wrote:

snip handwaving

when you supply equations that predict something DIFFERENT than
Maxwell please let me know, otherwise i need no snake oil.

p.s. talking energy when trying to figure out what happens with waves
is counterproductive. *energy is an integration of power, power is a
function of current or voltage and impedance, or field strength and
impedance of the medium... when you go from fields or current/voltage
to power you lose phase information that is important. *integrating it
into energy loses even the phase and time information. *it is always
best to describe waves by using one field or the other, which one is
up to the student since they are always related by the impedance of
the medium... the same goes for currents or voltages on conductors,
pick one and stick with it, you can always calculate the other when
needed.

You stated that nobody knows how waves work so I took energy
contained as the route. I can't explain how waves work either and I
don't want to start of with an explanation how a wave works.
So the impasse appears to me that first I have to explain how waves
work instead of mass but also to continue on with the same theory and
then apply it to another theory! It was stated earlier that a mouse
trap can kill a mouse with less than 100% energy, so you require an
autopsy to show how and why and if it is really dead! You can do the
same by connecting a radio up to a mesh. You find how it can transmit
and receive such that it is NOT dead, that is the easy way.
We are now back to the prosecutor declaring one is an idiot where the
judge retorts, as another example of free speech, that the prosequtor
is a homosexual, but now requests the prosequtor to present evidence
proof or you will be arrested!
I am not guilty as I have presented a paper for my peers to agree or
disagree on the basis of science. Unfortunately my peers in science
have not yet arrived. Either way, thanks a bunch for your efforts and
sticking to physics and not free speech.
Best Regards
Art