View Single Post
  #172   Report Post  
Old June 18th 10, 09:23 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
lu6etj lu6etj is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Jul 2006
Posts: 143
Default Where does it go? (mismatched power)

On 18 jun, 16:02, Cecil Moore wrote:
On Jun 18, 1:28*pm, K1TTT wrote:

Do you agree that wave reflection can cause a redistribution of wave
energy?


no. *wave reflection causes current and voltage waves to change
direction, magnitude, and phase.


The question asked by the original poster is, exactly what happens to
the reflected energy? Optical physicists know that a reversal of
energy flow direction accompanies the change in direction of the E-
field and the B-field which changes the direction of the ExB Poynting
vector, i.e. changes the "direction and momentum" of the EM wave
according to Eugene Hecht. How can you not know that a voltage/current
wave requires energy? How can the voltage and current change direction
without the energy changing direction? Does supernatural intervention
separate the voltage and current from the ExH energy?

Maybe you should reference, "Fields and Waves ...", by Ramo and
Whinnery where they describe the forward and reflected power-density
Poynting vectors.

Do you agree that superposition can cause a redistribution of wave
energy?


your observed 'redistribution of wave energy' is a results of
superposition of current and voltage waves and then another
calculation to convert the sum to power and another calculation to
integrate the energy.


Is that a yes or no answer? The same thing happens with light waves in
free space where voltage and current are completely irrelevant.

Do you agree that wave reflection and wave superposition are two
different mechanisms?


of course, i've never said otherwise.


You sure implied otherwise. Why did you argue with me when I said they
are two different mechanisms in action to redistribute energy, (1)
reflection and (2) superposition? You said superposition is not the
second mechanism.
--
73, Cecil, w5dxp.com


"-Do you agree that wave reflection can cause a redistribution of
wave
energy?-"
"-No. wave reflection causes current and voltage waves to change
direction, magnitude, and phase.-"

You see? Babel curse...! One ask about energy other answer with
current, voltage, etc. (same thing divided in pieces).

Do you agree cars have engines?, ˇOf course not! ˇcars have
crankshaft, cylinder, piston, rods...!
Thus you are never going to reach an agreement