View Single Post
  #128   Report Post  
Old June 25th 10, 12:30 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
K1TTT K1TTT is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Apr 2010
Posts: 484
Default what happens to reflected energy ?

On Jun 25, 7:46*am, lu6etj wrote:
On 24 jun, 17:54, K1TTT wrote:



On Jun 24, 3:25*pm, Cecil Moore wrote:


On Jun 24, 9:20*am, lu6etj wrote:


Oh, I'm so sorry Cecil, I should have written "However I can not
visualize a simple PHYSICAL mechanism/example to generate
such system in a TL". Anyway, your additional info it is very useful to
me. Thanks.


The physical mechanism is the Z01==Z02 impedance discontinuity with
its associated reflection coefficient, rho. We can see that reflection
on a TDR so it is indeed a PHYSICAL mechanism.
--
73, Cecil, w5dxp.com


don't forget the OTHER physical mechanism that is necessary,
superposition... the ability to add voltages, currents, and fields in
linear circuits and media.


I mentioned same comment in another post. We use superposition
principle in two different contexts. Superposition theorem in circuit
theory, and wave superposition. Wave (traveling) superposition deals
with f(t,x,y,z) and usually with puntual magnitudes, E, H, D, B, etc)
while circuit theory deals with a subset f(t) phenomena and with
integrated magnitudes (V, I). Sometimes that becomes a confused
issue

Miguel


NO, superposition is always the same. it is the linear addition of
currents or fields in a linear media. it works the same for circuits
as for em waves.

the big problem are the people who confuse the formulas for adding
powers with adding fields or currents/voltages and forget the phase
terms.

the other big problem is keith who seems to want to separate his waves
into separate time and space variables and leaves out the requirement
that wave functions must be dependent on both space AND time.
basically any solution to the wave equations derived from maxwell's
laws must be of the form f(t-x/v). this leads him to the erroneous
conclusions he gets from trying to compare his batteries to wave
propagation. this is the same problem people have with standing
waves, they have separate dependence on t and x, so they can't travel
and can't transport energy.