Ah, just the person I've been waiting for. How do you account for
current bunching on the conductors (that is, non-uniform distribution of
current around the conductors)? What reference, equation, or program do
you use? Nearly all "first principle" calculations of Q I've seen
grossly overestimate Q, and I believe the failure to take this into
account is at least part of the reason. I haven't seen a decent
analytical method of dealing with it, and an anxious to see how you do it.

Then there's surface corrosion and roughness, radiation, and coupling to
nearby objects. How do you deal with those? Have you identified some of
the other factors that often make a simplistic "first principle"
calculation disagree so badly with carefully made measurements?

Roy Lewallen, W7EL

James Meyer wrote:

If you have to "do the math", you might as well just calculate the Q
from first principles and forget the "measurement".

Jim