Thread: Trap antenna
View Single Post
  #6   Report Post  
Old October 27th 11, 08:52 PM posted to rec.radio.amateur.antenna
Owen Duffy Owen Duffy is offline
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Dec 2006
Posts: 1,169
Default Trap antenna

"Sal" wrote in :

....

Say, after following the link, above, I just took a look at that
AIM4170 web site and it looks like it's more trouble to get it up and
running than most things. A lot of the steps are left to the
imagination ... or they assume a whole lot about what potential buyers
already know.


Sal, I bought an AimUHF, and it worked fine out of the box.

I suspect that the problem that most hams encounter with analysers and
VNAs is that the knowledge of basic complex numbers, AC circuit theory,
transmission lines, and antenna systems does not 'come in the box'.

If acquiring such a thing is the stimulus for expanding knowledge on
those topics using the box as a learning aid, that is great. But to
many, they are safer to just treat it as a VSWR measuring device.

I am staggered by the popular advice offered to newbies who ask 'why is
my VSWR high' on eHam and QRZ to borrow an analyser. The advice appears
to offered mainly by people who don't understand the instruments, and
possibly have never used them effectively.

A classic example is the advice to connect the instrument at the shack
end and tune for resonance, for as everyone knows, "an antenna just
ain't gonna work any good unless it is resonate (sic)".

The getting of knowledge just isn't a priority in a world of instant
gratification.

Owen