View Single Post
  #8   Report Post  
Old September 17th 12, 03:43 PM
Channel Jumper Channel Jumper is offline
Senior Member
 
First recorded activity by RadioBanter: Jan 2011
Posts: 390
Default

The bottom line is - not everyone is as compute savy as you are.
There really is some stupid people out there in this world.
It's easier for them - TODAY - to just punch in the zip code and have the radio program itself then for them to actually research the bands and have to do some work.

The problem is - PUBLIC SAFETY is in a constant state of flux.
Just because this is the frequencies used today - does not mean they will be the same frequencies used tomorrow.

Pennsylvania is a very prime example.

The State Police were on the VHF portion of the band 154 - 156 MHz and still are in some locations such as McKeon and Potter county - where digital modes - one stick every mile on a telephone pole just doesn't work - the hills are too steep and the valleys too deep to get good digital penetration from the 800 MHz equipment presently being used.

The Fire Departments has migrated from the low band - 46 MHz to 155.730 county dispatch to the 460 - 470 MHz..
However - places such as Indiana county still uses their old 33 MHz - and are going to be screwed when it comes time to switch to narrow band and a higher more compatiable frequency - because they probably use 3 or 4 towers now to fulfill their obligation to cover the whole county and will have to double the amount of repeater sites to do the same thing - if possible on 460 MHz.

When you have Rossiter on the northern end of the county - down in a deep valley, you cannot talk simplex to Indiana PA or Commodore or Creekside or Homer City or Blairsville PA.

The only thing the FCC will be able to do is grant them a extension until they can find a better way of doing it with the available equipment.
Most all equipment made after 1994 - I believe has the capability if being narrowbanded - so most equipment made before 1994 is probably been taken out of service.

The problem with their equipment is - it cannot be easily modified to work on higher frequencies - which means each and every fire company and repeater would need all new equipment.

I believe it was President Harry S. Truman that said it is a recession when your neighbor looses his job and it is a depression when you loose your job.

In a down economy - where very little support is being given to volunteer fire companies - it is hard to tell a bunch of people working out of their own pockets that they have to buy new radios and equipment.

The State Police operates on a outdated system called OPEN SKY - which already has a updated number - like going from windows 98 to windows XP...
It won't be long before they have to have another update.
And it is a proprietary type system - hence you can't listen to it anyways.

So how do you program a scanner - with general coverage - that can do all of this?

And my other question is - what about amateur radio?

Most scanners already does 140 MHz and 440 MHz - but no one thinks of including those frequencies into the pre programmed bands.
And, even if they did, they run the risk of repeaters being shut off, repeaters being moved to a different frequency and repeater frequencies being hyjacked by gas company monitoring systems or harmonic's of other public use frequenices harmonic's over powering those frequencies.

Most of the low band equipment being taken off the air here - was sold to other less populated places such as Montana and Idaho - where the population is spread out and where a good low band radio will out talk a better VHF / UHF radio..
It is more practical for those people to still use 33 - 48 MHz for their communications needs.

The whole pre programmed scheme is doomed to fail.

And people who subscribe to that type of service, and then wants only certain type of things on their radios will never be satisfied because each time the power goes out and each time they unplug it - they run the risk of loosing everything that was programmed and you will have to keep coming back again and reprogramming their radio for them.

The bottom line is - give a man a fish and he will eat for a day.
Teach a man HOW to FISH and he will eat for a lifetime.

I don't accept people who says they are old or crippled and cannot do something to be a valid reason to do things for them.
If they want to listen - make them learn how to operate it and let them program it on their own.
We need to stop catering to these dumb people and start educating these people and make them more productive.

I go through this all the time with amateur radio operators who does not know how to program their own radio and only talks simplex because they don't have to program in the offset and PL...
That in my book is called the CB radio - not ham radio...