On 7/6/2015 11:01 AM, Jerry Stuckle wrote:
On 7/6/2015 4:20 AM, Ian Jackson wrote:
In message , rickman writes



How about we quit with the speculation and come up with some numbers?

Here is a simulation of a 50 ohm load with a 50 ohm matched series
output impedance and a voltage source of 200 VAC peak. Power into the
load is 100 W.

http://arius.com/sims/Matched%20Load%20Power.png

Same exact circuit with the series impedance of just 1 ohm, power into
the load is 385 W.

http://arius.com/sims/UnMatched%20Load%20Power.png

I'd say that is pretty clear evidence that matched loads are not the
way to maximize power transfer when the load impedance is fixed and
the output impedance is controllable.

Quite simply, if your prime objective is to get maximum power out of a
power (energy?) source, the source having an internal resistance is a
BAD THING. You don't design the source to have an internal resistance
equal to its intended load resistance. No one designs lead-acid
batteries that way (do they?), so why RF transmitters?

While theoretically you can extract the maximum power available from the
source when the load resistance equals the source resistance, you can
only do so provided that the heat you generate in the source does not
cause the source to malfunction (in the worst case, blow up).

Because DC power transfer is not the same as AC power transfer.


Why not? Does something happen to the laws of physics with AC?


If what you say is correct, then it wouldn't matter what antenna
impedance I had, as long as it matches the transmission line. VSWR
would be immaterial.


There is no VSWR nor ISWR if the load matches the line.


That is demonstrably false.

Please demonstrate this for us as we wish to learn.