"Dick Carroll" wrote in message
...
Carl R. Stevenson wrote:

I wouldn't oppose a bit more "meat" on the Extra written ... but I
would oppose any "time in grade" requirements. Folks either
qualify (pass the test) or not ... "time in grade" unnecessarily
discriminates against people who are qualified by making them
wait unnecessarily.

So you believe a few supplied-answer questions on a couple written
tests, with little technical content, a few memorized band edges and a
few rules, no operational testing of any sort, with no experience record
whatever, makes an expert rahwdyo amatooer.

So much for that sensible NCI position!

First, I didn't say it was an NCI position ... I was expressing my personal
view. If I state an NCI position, it will be clearly identified as such,
otherwise, it's my personal comment.

Second, what part of "more 'meat' on the Extra written don't you
understand??? You say "with little technical content" ... where'd
you pull that out of? I never said that.

Your zeal to attack anything I say, even if you might actually agree
with the substance if you actually UNDERSTOOD what I said,
and then try to spin your distortion as "NCI position" is telling.

Carl - wk3c